Skip to content
Help Center

Create a similar ad from a reference ad ​

Create similar ad takes an ad you like and opens a new creative batch with that ad as its starting point. You choose the product and generate the images on the batch screen. Commander keeps the ad with the batch, so you can preview it from the header.

Problem and intended user ​

The creative strategist (the person who plans and makes ad creatives) often sees an ad that works well, such as a competitor ad or one of the store's own ads. Making a new ad in the same style for another product takes design work. Meanwhile the media buyer (the person who runs your paid ads) keeps running older creatives.

Current workflow ​

Without Commander, the creative strategist saves a screenshot of the reference ad. The strategist then briefs an agency, or rebuilds the layout in a design tool with the product photo. The result goes into Meta Ads Manager or Google Ads as a new ad.

Prerequisites ​

  • A reference that is an image ad. Commander cannot work from video ads or text-only ads.
  • A product that has a usable photo.
  • Enough credits. See Credits and top-ups.

How Commander works ​

Create similar ad only fills in the batch setup. It starts no batch and spends no credits. It is an ordinary creative batch: AI image models make the images from your product. Commander sends the reference ad's picture to the image model as an example of the look to follow. It also records the ad as the batch's starting point and shows it as a card in the batch header, so you can compare. To follow the look of the ad without its words, tick No text on image under Image in the settings button’s popover. Commander still uses the ad’s picture as the example and leaves the words out.

You approve two points. You finish the setup and select Generate creatives. Later you decide which images to keep, and Commander sends nothing to Creatives until you do. Generate creatives depends on your product photos. Commander prepares them when you pick a product, and the button stays off until they are ready.

Start from a reference ad ​

Select Create similar ad on any of these:

ReferenceWhere to find it
A competitor adInspiration Library > Competitors > Competitor Library, on a card or in its viewer. See Competitor Library.
One of your adsPerformance > Ad performance, on a row, in the ad's detail dialog, or on its Ad detail page. See Ad performance.
A Library imageCreate > Library, on an image card. See Library.
A Studio adCreate > Ads, on a card or in its detail drawer. See Review and deploy ads.

On a tight card the button reads Create similar. A video ad or a text-only ad shows no button. If you reach the setup for one anyway, it opens empty and says "Similar ads can’t be made from video ads" or "Similar ads can’t be made from text-only ads". If the ad was removed, it says so and opens empty.

For a carousel, the reference is the card you chose.

Set up the batch ​

The setup opens on the batch screen, titled New creative batch, with the ad as its starting point.

What the ad brings depends on where it came from:

ReferenceWhat is filled in
One of your ads, a Library image or a Studio adThe product it is linked to, when it has one.
A competitor adNothing of yours. Choose a product.
  1. Check the product box. If it is empty, select the Product box that reads Choose a product and pick one, as in Generate creatives on the batch screen.
  2. Select the reference ad's card in the header to check it. Preview opens the full ad in place. Select the card again, or press Esc, to close it.
  3. If a product says No usable photo, add a photo to it in Shopify or choose another product.

The setup has no angle, scene or creative preset. The reference ad is the look and the direction, and Generate creatives does not need anything more than a product. The product's photo options and Keep as is stay.

When you pick a product, Commander prepares its photos. Generate creatives turns on by itself when they are ready. If it is off, the screen says why, for example "Choose a product to generate images."

Generate ​

WARNING

Generate creatives spends credits. Check the price next to it before you select it.

Choose the model and the image quantity if you want to change them, then select Generate creatives. The cost shows beside the button when your plan uses credits. The Billing page lists the current price of each action. If you do not have enough credits, Commander opens the top-up dialog. The usual limits for creative batches apply, and the screen tells you when you reach one.

Review the batch ​

Commander opens the batch screen for the new batch. The images appear as they finish. You can leave the page. The batch keeps going. The header reads "similar to" and the ad's name. Select the ad's card to preview the full ad. The results keep the full width.

Review the images as in any creative batch. See Review and keep your creatives.

Batches made earlier with the Similar Ad Wizard keep their own page, with Keep selected and no Discard button. See Review a similar-ad batch.

Exact output ​

You get the images of one creative batch, on the batch screen.

The header reads "similar to" and the ad's name. The ad's card shows its thumbnail, name and kind. Preview opens the full ad in place and closes it again. It stays closed until you open it. In Creative batches, a batch started from an ad shows the ad's picture and "Similar to:" with its name.

Find the batch later ​

Open Create > Creative batches, select Filters and set Starting point to Similar to an ad. Select the button on the batch to open it. See Creative batches.

What to do with it ​

What you seeDecision or actionOwner
An image you want to runSelect Keep, then choose platforms. See Review and keep your creativescreative strategist
An image that is close but not rightAdjust it on the batch screencreative strategist
An image you do not wantSelect Discardcreative strategist
A kept imageOpen the Set in Creatives and turn it into an ad. See Review and deploy adsmedia buyer
A competitor ad you used as a referenceCheck that the claims, prices and offers in the image are true for your store before you run it. This check happens outside Commanderecommerce manager (the person who runs the store)

Expected value and measurement ​

This flow can help you test a style you have seen elsewhere, with your own product, without a design brief for each ad.

To check the batch, open Create > Creative batches, set Filters > Starting point to Similar to an ad and read the count on each batch. To check the ads, open Performance > Ad performance, find the new ads and compare their Spend and ROAS with the reference ad when it is one of yours. Use the same dates and platform. A competitor ad has no results there, so compare with your own earlier ads. Other changes at the same time can hide the effect.

Limitations and exceptions ​

  • Not supported. Video ads, text-only ads and products without a usable photo.
  • AI output can be wrong. A generated image can differ from your product or contain flaws. Review each image before you keep it.
  • The reference picture guides the look, it is not copied. Every image of the batch is made with the reference picture as an example, next to your product photo. The images follow its layout and style. They show your product, and they do not repeat another brand's logo, name, product or text. For a carousel, the picture is the card you chose.
  • When the reference picture is no longer available. If the ad was removed or its picture has expired (an image that is too small is different: see Source problems), Commander does not start the batch and does not charge you. See the next point.
  • Source problems. "We couldn’t open that ad. It may have been removed." means the ad was removed, or belongs to another store. "That ad could not be loaded, so nothing is preselected." means a read failed. Go back and choose Create similar ad again. "This ad's image is too small to clone. Choose an ad with a larger image." appears on the create screen when you create from an ad whose stored image is too small. Commander does not start the batch and does not charge you. Go back and choose another ad. Some ads only store a tiny badge image, not the ad itself.
  • No angle, scene or preset to choose. The setup does not offer them. Commander makes the images from the reference picture and your product only.
  • The batch needs the reference picture. If the reference picture can no longer be loaded, Commander does not start the batch and does not charge you. The screen says "The picture of the ad this batch is similar to can’t be loaded, and a batch with no angle needs it. Choose an angle, or start a new batch from another ad." Start a new batch from another ad. The same happens when you generate another round.
  • Batch problems. A banner says how many images could not be generated. If a batch has not started after a while, contact support and quote the batch number. See Contact support.
  • Missing batch. "This batch could not be found" means it may be deleted. Select Back to Creative batches. For "The batch could not be loaded", reload.
  • Older batches. Batches made with the Similar Ad Wizard before this change keep their own page and still show under Similar to an ad.
  • Demo Mode. In Demo Mode the setup opens on sample data and the images are sample images. Nothing is stored in your store and the batch does not appear in Create > Creative batches.

Commander is built by Omniconvert.