Review and keep your creatives
When a round of images lands, you choose which ones to keep. Review them on the batch screen, in Create > Creative batches. A kept creative goes to Create > Creatives. Nothing reaches Creatives until you keep it.
Problem and intended user
The creative strategist (the person who plans and makes ad creatives) gets many images from one batch. Only some are good enough to run. Each platform also needs its own sizes. Without a clear review step, good images sit unused or go out in the wrong size. The media buyer (the person who runs your paid ads) needs the chosen images ready for a Meta or Google campaign.
Current workflow
Without Commander, the creative strategist reviews images in a folder or a shared design file. An agency or a design tool crops each chosen image for every placement. The media buyer then uploads the files by hand in Meta Ads Manager or Google Ads.
Prerequisites
- A batch with at least one finished image. See Generate creatives on the batch screen.
- The platforms you plan to use, Meta, Google or both. Commander asks for them when you keep a creative.
How Commander works
An AI model made the images in the batch. Commander shows them under the title Choose your visuals. You decide for each image: Keep or Discard.
WARNING
Keep is final. A kept creative cannot be un-kept, and the screen offers no undo. Check the image and the platforms before you select Keep.
Look at the images
The line under the title counts the batch, for example "N creatives · N kept". A count of discarded images joins it when you discard one.
- Choose a layout with the two buttons on the first round row. Focus shows one image at a time, with small pictures below to jump between images. Compare shows every image of a round side by side.
- Select See inputs on a round row to read what the round was made from. The Product box shows the photo that round was sent, which can differ from the product's main photo in Shopify. When a size photo or a cut-out was sent, a Scale photo or Cut-out box shows it. A round sent no cut-out shows no such box. Hide inputs closes it. Reuse these inputs copies them back into the batch, so you can change one ingredient and generate again.
- Wait for an image that reads "Creating your image…". The placeholder shows a timer with how long that image has been creating. Its buttons stay off until it lands.
- Select a finished image to see it full size. Use the arrows, or the left and right arrow keys, to move between the finished images, and close the view to come back to the batch.
Keep an image
- Select Keep under the image.
- Choose where you will use it. Select Meta, Google or both. Nothing is selected for you, and Keep stays off until you select one.
- Confirm the choice. The image then shows Kept and cannot change again.
The batch makes square (1:1) images, and a kept image goes to Create > Creatives at that size. For Meta, open the creative in the Studio editor and select Add aspect to add 4:5, 9:16 or 1.91:1 later. The Deployment Wizard makes the sizes an ad needs when you publish.
Discard an image
Select Discard under the image. The image stays in place, dimmed, with a Discarded label, so you can see what you decided. A discarded image can still be kept.
Go on to the next steps
As soon as one image has finished, a bar pinned to the bottom of the screen says where to go next. You do not have to keep or discard every image first. It is titled "2 of 4 reviewed · 1 kept" while some images have no decision yet, and "All 4 reviewed · 1 kept" once every image has one. The images without a decision stay as they are, and Keep and Discard stay available. The batch shows the Under review badge until every image is kept or discarded, then Reviewed.
The bar has one main button, and it depends on what you decided:
| You have | Main button | What it does |
|---|---|---|
| Kept at least one image | Use 1 kept creative (or Use 3 kept creatives) | Opens Create > Creatives. |
| Kept nothing, with images still undecided | None | The bar reads "Keep the ones you like to use them in ads." |
| Kept nothing, and every image decided | Generate again | Generates another round in the same batch. Adjust settings sits beside it. |
Once you have kept at least one image, Deploy 1 kept creative (or Deploy 3 kept creatives) also shows in the bar. It opens the Deployment Wizard with this batch's kept creatives already chosen, so you can publish them as Meta or Google ads.
More like these generates another round in the same batch, at the batch's image quantity. The ⋯ button on the bar holds Adjust settings, which returns to the ingredients, and Explore ideas, which opens Create > Creative ideas. When the batch cannot make more images, for example because it holds its 60 images, Adjust settings shows on the bar itself.
Exact output
You get a reviewed batch, and one creative in Create > Creatives for each image you kept.
Each round starts with the product its images were made for. Under it are the angle and the number of variants, for example "Energy without the afternoon crash · 4 variants". The images below are variants of one ad, not different ads. Each image has a caption, Creative NN, followed by its place in the round, for example Variant 2 of 4. A kept image shows Kept. A discarded image shows Discarded. In Focus, a small picture of each image sits below with a tick for kept and a cross for discarded.
Once you have kept an image, Use 1 kept creative in the bar opens it in Creatives.
Deploy 1 kept creative in the bar opens the Deployment Wizard with the batch's kept creatives already chosen.
What to do with it
| What you see | Decision or action | Owner |
|---|---|---|
| An image you would run | Select Keep, then choose the platforms. | creative strategist |
| An image with a wrong detail | Select Discard. Then generate another round with More like these. | creative strategist |
| A kept image | Open it in Create > Creatives, check the copy and turn it into an ad. See Review and deploy ads. | media buyer |
| A kept image you want to run on Meta or Google now | Select Deploy N kept creatives in the bar and follow the wizard. See Deployment Wizard. | media buyer |
| A batch that missed the idea | Select Adjust settings, change one ingredient, and generate again. | creative strategist |
Expected value and measurement
This step can help you send the images you judge strongest on to Creatives, where you can add sizes for Meta or let the Deployment Wizard make the sizes an ad needs, without cropping and copying by hand.
To check, open Create > Creatives and confirm that each kept image has a creative set. After the ads run, open Performance > Ad performance and read Spend and ROAS for ads built from this batch, next to your earlier ads over the same dates. No Commander page scores the review step itself. Other changes at the same time can hide the effect.
Limitations and exceptions
- AI output can be wrong. An image can show a wrong detail. Check each one.
- Not offered. The batch screen has no Refine, no Remix, no previous versions, no reactions and no Prepare ad. It has no free-text instructions. You cannot undo a keep or restore a discarded image to its earlier state.
- Earlier batches. Earlier batches open read-only. So does a batch whose look (style, copy, font and logo) is not exactly one preset. They show their images with Keep and Discard and no Generate. In this viewer, Keep asks only for the platforms. It asks for no sizes.
- Older Meta creatives. A Meta creative kept as a single image has no Add aspect in the Studio editor, which shows it as a single-design Set. The Deployment Wizard makes the sizes an ad needs when you publish.
- Deploy button. Deploy N kept creatives shows only once you have kept an image. In Demo Mode it opens the wizard, which creates nothing on Meta or Google.
- Demo Mode. The batch screen shows a sample data badge. The images are samples, and nothing you keep is stored in your store.