Ad performance: see which ads make money
The Ad performance page shows how your Meta and Google ads did in the dates you pick. Open it from Performance > Ad performance. Four headline numbers sit at the top. A stats strip and the What's working table sit below them.
Problem and intended user
This page is for the media buyer (the person who runs your paid ads) and the ecommerce manager (the person who runs the store). Ad platforms report revenue they credit to themselves. That figure does not show what your store kept after ad spend, so you can fund ads that look good and still lose margin.
Current workflow
You read the platform-reported return in Meta Ads Manager and Google Ads. You export the results to a spreadsheet and match spend against profit from Shopify admin reports. To group ads by concept, product or offer, you tag each ad by hand or ask an agency.
Prerequisites
- Connect Meta Ads, Google Ads or both. Wait for the first ad sync to finish.
- Your order and customer data, which Commander connects by itself. It fills Gross profit after ad spend, Predicted revenue return and True profit. Until that data exists for the period, they show a dash.
- Ads that Commander has analysed, for the creative views: By concept, By angle, By hook, By offer and the views in the More… list. By ad, By product, By collection, By campaign, By ad set / ad group and By creative type do not need this.
How Commander works
Commander reads your synced Meta and Google ad data and your order data. Fixed rules add up the numbers and group the ads. In a separate step, AI analyses each ad's creative and sets its concept, angle, hook, offer, trigger, visual, awareness level, message clarity, text density and scroll-stop power. The creative views group ads by these answers only. Nothing here changes your ad accounts, and no step needs an approval.
Choose dates and a platform
Use the date picker for the period. This page covers at most 400 days, so wider presets are hidden. If you pick a longer range, the picker reads Showing last 400 days.
Choose All Platforms, Google or Meta above the numbers.
Sync your ad data
Commander also syncs your connected ad accounts on its own. Settings > Store Status lists the Meta ads sync and Google ads sync rows. See Store Status.
A status bar shows how many ads are synced and when the last sync ran. It offers Sync Now and Full Sync. While a sync runs, Cancel replaces both buttons.
- Sync Now pulls the newest ad data for the platform in view. On All Platforms, it covers both platforms.
- Full Sync pulls a longer history again. Its label shows the backfill window in days, for example Full Sync (90d). The default is 90. The arrow beside it opens a Backfill window menu with 90 days, 120 days, 180 days and 365 days.
The menu note explains the window. Days Commander already has are skipped for spend and metrics, and only missing days are pulled. Commander recomputes profit attribution in full for the window you choose.
On the Meta or Google view, the status bar also ends with the window in days and one of three coverage notes: coverage complete — nothing new to fetch, fetched only missing days or full fetch.
Group the table
The What's working table lists your ads in groups. A sentence under the heading says what the current view groups by. Switch views with these buttons.
| View | Groups ads by |
|---|---|
| By concept | The creative concept Commander found in each ad. This is the default. |
| By angle | The buying argument each ad makes. The grey text after an angle's name is its family: the broader outcome the buyer wants, such as Reduce effort. |
| By ad | Nothing. Every creative stands alone. |
| By hook | How each ad opens. |
| By product | The product each ad links to. Ads that match no product form a separate group. |
| By collection | The Shopify collections of the advertised product. |
| By offer | The offer each ad leads with. |
| By trigger | The customer problem each ad speaks to. |
| By visual | The main visual style of the ad. |
| By awareness | How aware of the problem the ad assumes the viewer is. |
| By message clarity | How clear the ad's message is. |
| By text density | How much text is on the creative. |
| By scroll-stop power | How strongly the opening of the ad stops the scroll. |
| By campaign | The campaign each ad runs in. Ads with no linked campaign form a No campaign linked group. |
| By ad set / ad group | The Meta ad set, the Google ad group or the Performance Max asset group each ad runs in. Each row names which one it is: Ad set, Ad group or Asset group. A Performance Max asset group is its own group, named as in Google Ads, with its campaign beside the name. An asset group that Commander has not synced yet forms a Performance Max (asset group not synced) group. |
| By creative type | Static, video, carousel, text, or Shopping and Performance Max. |
The buttons are By concept, By angle, By ad, By hook, By product, By collection, By offer, By campaign, By ad set / ad group and By creative type. By trigger, By visual, By awareness, By message clarity, By text density and By scroll-stop power sit in a list that reads More…, after the buttons. Its name for a screen reader is More creative views. The list shows the view you picked. On a phone or a narrow window, the buttons and the list become one Group by list. It holds every view in four sets: Creative, Products, Structure and Ungrouped.
The groups at the end of a creative view
The ten creative views end with up to four fixed groups. They are By concept, By angle, By hook, By offer and the six views in the More… list. They always come after your other groups, in this order. A group shows only when the period holds an ad for it.
| Group | What it holds |
|---|---|
| Performance Max | Your Performance Max asset groups. They mix many assets, so Commander does not place them on these views. |
| No benefit claim | Appears in By angle only. Commander analysed these ads and found no benefit claim. They show the product, a price or an offer only. |
| Unplaced | Commander analysed these ads, but none of the options fits well enough. |
| Unclassified | Commander has not analysed these ads yet. |
Each fixed group has a note beside its name that says the same. These groups get no verdict, and they have no magnifier.
When every ad set holds exactly one ad, a line above the table says that Commander launches one ad set per ad, so By ad set / ad group mirrors By ad.
Select the arrow on a group to see its ads. Select an ad name to open its Ad detail page.
Preview an ad
Select an ad's thumbnail to open a preview of its creative. The preview helps you tell ads apart before you open one.
- An image ad shows its image. A video ad plays its video.
- When Commander did not store the video, the preview shows the poster frame and says Video not stored.
- A text ad has no creative, and the preview says so.
- Under the creative, the preview shows the ad's platform, format and delivery status. When the ad belongs to a campaign, it also shows a Campaign line with the campaign's name.
- View ad details opens the Ad detail page.
For most ads, the preview also has a Pause or Start button. The Ad detail page has the same buttons in its header.
- Pause stops the ad on Meta or Google at once. You can start it again.
- Start asks you to confirm first. If the ad has never run on the platform, the confirmation says that starting it is the ad's first spend.
- When neither button shows, a note under the status says why: the platform stopped the ad, or its ad set or campaign is paused. Fix that on Meta or Google.
- Performance Max ads have no Pause or Start button.
Press Esc or select the close button to close the preview.
Open a group panel
Select the magnifier icon beside a group's name to open the group panel next to the table. A group is, for example, a concept, a product or a campaign. The fixed groups at the end of a creative view have no magnifier, and ad rows have none either. On a phone, the panel fills the screen. The top of the panel shows the group's name, what kind of group it is and its verdict. Below it:
- Numbers. Spend, revenue, ROAS, predicted revenue return, true profit and spend share, for the dates you picked. They match the group's row in the table. The information icon beside a number shows its formula with the group's own values.
- Daily trend. A chart of spend and revenue for each day in your dates. Show daily figures opens the same numbers, with each day's ROAS, as a table.
- Ads. The group's ads, biggest spend first. Select an ad to open its Ad detail page. Show all lists the rest when the group has many ads.
- Open product page. A link to the product's page, shown on By product only. Angles, concepts and the other groups have no page of their own.
Press Esc or select Close to close the group panel. If it cannot load, the panel says so in red and offers Try again.
Filter by recent spend
Use All, Spent recently and No recent spend next to the view buttons.
- Spent recently shows ads that spent within 7 days of the latest synced day. Hover over the button to read this.
- No recent spend shows ads with no spend within 7 days of the latest synced day.
These buttons go by recent spend. They do not read the ad's status on the platform. A just-paused ad can still show under Spent recently until its last day of spend leaves that window. The information icon beside the buttons explains this.
Show active ads only
Select Active ads only to keep the ads that Meta or Google report as active. It hides paused, archived, disapproved and with-issues ads. It reads the same status as the Status column. Select it again to show every status.
Filter by format
- Select Format. The button reads Format: All until you pick one.
- Tick Static, Video, Carousel or any mix of them. The button shows the one format you picked, or how many you picked.
- Select Clear format to see every format again.
Static covers image, collection and stories ads. Video covers video and Reels ads. Search text ads and Shopping & Performance Max match none of the three, so any format you pick hides them.
How the filters combine
The spend buttons, Active ads only and Format work together. An ad shows only when it passes all of them. A group keeps only its matching ads, and its figures cover those ads. A group with no matching ad disappears. A line under the toolbar names the filters in use.
Verdicts still compare each row with your whole account. The headline numbers include all ads. If no ad matches, the table says so. Select Show all ads to clear all three filters at once.
Your choices stay in the page address, so a shared link opens the same filters.
Filter by source
Use All, Commander and Other next to the recent spend buttons. Commander keeps the ads that Commander launched from a creative it generated. Other keeps every ad made elsewhere, including a copy of a Commander ad. An edited Commander ad stays under Commander.
The filter narrows the ads you see. A group with no matching ad disappears. A group that stays still shows its own numbers, and those cover all of its ads. A line under the toolbar says so. If no ad matches, select Show all sources.
The choice stays in the page address, so a shared link opens the same filter.
Search for an ad, campaign or ad set
- Type in Search ads, campaigns, ad sets or ad IDs, next to the view buttons. Part of a name is enough, and capitals do not matter.
- Read the line under the buttons. It says how many ads match, for example 3 of 24 ads match.
- Open a group to see its matching ads. On a grouped view, a group that holds a matching ad opens on its own, with just the matching ads in it.
- Select the X in the field (Clear search) to see every ad again.
The search matches an ad by its name, its platform ad ID, its campaign name and its ad set name. It matches a group by the group's name. A group that matches by its own name keeps all of its ads and does not open on its own. It does not match the internal IDs Commander keeps for each ad.
The search works together with the spend, status, format and source filters: it looks only at the ads they leave. It keeps your text when you switch views. The text stays in the page address, so a shared link opens the same search.
A link from an Insights finding opens the By ad view with the ad's name already in the field and the ad's row highlighted. The row stays in the list even if its name does not match the text, until you edit the search or change the view or a filter. If a filter hides the ad, a note reads The row you followed isn't in this list. A filter may be hiding it. Select Show all ads.
Search covers only the rows loaded on the page. When a note says that some rows are missing or cannot expand, search skips those too. If no ad matches, the table says No ads match and your text. Select Clear search, or try a shorter part of the name.
Choose the columns
Select Metrics to open the Metrics shown menu. Tick or clear a column. Select Reset to restore the defaults. Name always stays. To reorder, drag a column header, or focus it and press Alt+Shift with the left or right arrow key.
The defaults are Name, Status, Campaign, Creative type, Spend, Spend share, ROAS, CPA, Predicted revenue return, Transactions, New customers, nCAC, Trend and Verdict. You can add Ad set / Ad group, Source, Impressions, Clicks, CPM, Launched, Hook rate, Hold rate, ThruPlay rate, Cost per ThruPlay, Reach and Frequency from the same menu. If you hid a column before it became a default, it stays hidden. Commander keeps every column choice you made.
If you connect Klar, the menu also offers Klar orders, Klar revenue, Klar ROAS and Klar CM2. They are hidden until you tick them, and they show only for ads and campaigns. A Klar model list and a coverage note appear while one of them shows. See Connect Klar.
Status, Campaign, Ad set / Ad group, Creative type, Source and Launched describe a single ad. A group row shows a dash in them.
| Column | What it shows |
|---|---|
| Status | What Meta or Google reports for the ad now: Active, Paused, Archived, Disapproved, With issues or Unknown. It takes the ad's campaign and ad set into account, so an ad that is switched on can read Paused when its campaign is paused. |
| Campaign | The campaign the ad runs in. |
| Ad set / Ad group | The Meta ad set or Google ad group. |
| Creative type | Static, Video, Carousel, Text or Shopping & Performance Max. |
| Source | A Commander badge when Commander launched the ad from a creative it generated. Other for every other ad. |
| Impressions and Clicks | The totals in the period. A group shows the total of its ads. |
| CPM | Spend per thousand impressions. |
| Launched | The day Commander first saw the ad. On Google it is the first sync that saw the ad, so it stands in for the launch day. |
| New customers and nCAC | First orders Commander matched to the row, and the spend per new customer. |
| Hook rate, Hold rate, ThruPlay rate and Cost per ThruPlay | How Meta video ads hold attention. Other ads show a dash. |
| Reach and Frequency | People the row's Meta ads reached, and how often they saw them. Google ads show a dash. |
Select the information icon beside a column name to read how Commander calculates it. The Metrics menu shows the same formula under each column. In the ROAS, Predicted revenue return and True profit cells, a second icon shows the same formula with that row's own numbers. On a phone, the icon sits beside each label on the card. Columns and verdicts explains each one. It also covers the Pro button, the alternative to Simple at the top of the page. Pro replaces the table with creative fatigue charts.
Share an ad or make a list
To show one of your ads to someone outside your team, open the … menu on the ad's row, beside the Create landing page button (its name for a screen reader is "More actions for" and the ad name), and select Share…. Or open the ad's Ad detail page and select Share in the header, beside Copy link. In the Share dialog, choose a Link lifetime, select Create link and copy the link. The person who opens the link needs no Commander account. See Share a creative, a folder or a list with a link.
To share several ads with one link, tick the checkbox at the start of each ad row. A bar at the bottom reads "N of 100 selected". Select Create list, type a List name and select Create. Then select Share list to make a link, or Done. The bar's Clear button empties the selection. Your picks stay ticked when you change pages of the table. Find your lists and links in Lists and links: on Create > Creatives or Create > Ads, open the More page actions menu (…). See Lists and links.
In the By concept and By angle views, tick the checkbox on a concept or angle row to select its ads at once. The fixed groups at the end have no checkbox. Select Create list, and the List name is already filled in, for example "Angle: Social proof". See Share a creative, a folder or a list with a link.
The bar can also show Generate landing pages (N). That button works for up to 20 ads at a time. See Landing pages.
Exact output
The four headline numbers
| Number | What it shows |
|---|---|
| You spent | Total ad spend in the period, and the change from the prior period. |
| Platform-reported revenue | The revenue Meta and Google say your ads drove, with the return and its change from the prior period. |
| Matched revenue | Revenue from orders Commander tied to a specific ad, with the order count and the profit after cost of goods. |
| Gross profit after ad spend | Your whole store's profit from your order data, minus total ad spend, with the margin. |
Select the information icon beside a card's name to read how Commander calculates that number.
A dash on a card comes with a reason line. Matched revenue shows a dash with no orders matched to ads yet when Commander has matched no order. Gross profit after ad spend shows a dash when Commander has no order data for the period. A line at the bottom says what share of the period's orders Commander matched to a specific ad. A low share means Matched revenue understates what your ads drove.
When some live ads cannot be traced to the ad, an alert appears above the numbers. For Meta, it says how many live ads are missing URL parameters and lists the four parameters to add to each ad in Meta Ads Manager, under Tracking > URL parameters. It also says how many of those ads were created in the last 24 hours, and when Commander last checked. Check now re-reads the Meta ads Commander already has. It also reads ads you created in Meta Ads Manager since the last sync, so a new ad counts at once. The button reads Checking… until it finishes. Ads published from Commander are not flagged. If Triple Whale is connected in Commander, Meta ads tagged with Triple Whale's ad ID parameter (tw_adid) count as tracked and are not flagged either. For Google, the alert says how many live ads it cannot trace and that the account-level Final URL suffix lacks utm_content. Live Meta ads without delivery in the selected dates, such as scheduled ads, are checked too. If any of them are missing URL parameters, the alert says how many, even when nothing else needs fixing. When the alert shows for Google and no Meta ad needs correcting, a Meta line says so and when Commander last checked.
The stats strip
A strip of five tiles sits between the headline numbers and the table. It reads the same dates and platform. Select a tile's name to read how Commander counts it.
| Tile | What it shows |
|---|---|
| Share of ad spend | How the spend splits by platform, as a share of the spend on individual ads. When you filter or search the table, it reads Selected ads = with the share that the ads on show hold. |
| Spend by creative type | A bar and a legend with five types: static, video, carousel, text, and Shopping and Performance Max. Each carries its share of spend. |
| Ads launched | How many ads Commander first saw in the period, and of which how many via Commander. |
| Creatives generated | How many Commander-generated ads were created in the period, except rejected ones, and how many of them reached Meta or Google. View generated ads opens the list. |
| Commander vs other ads | ROAS and Predicted revenue return for Commander ads next to all other ads. |
The shares use the spend on individual ads as their total. Google campaign-level spend with no ad rows is left out, so that total can differ from You spent. Meta ads whose media Commander could not read can count as text. On Google, Ads launched leaves out Performance Max asset groups.
When Commander ads hold only a very small share of spend, or there are only a few of them, Commander vs other ads reads Too few Commander ads in this period to compare instead of two ratios. Commander matches orders less well for ads it did not create, which affects Predicted revenue return more than ROAS.
The What's working table
Each row is one group of ads in the current view, with the columns you chose. Verdicts compare each row with your whole account, even when you filter by spend, status, format or source. The headline numbers and the stats strip tiles always cover all ads. The only exception is the Selected ads = line in Share of ad spend.
What to do with it
| What you see | Decision or action | Owner |
|---|---|---|
| Gross profit after ad spend is low or falling | Decide whether to cut or move ad budget. | ecommerce manager |
| A group with high Spend and a weak Verdict | Pause a weak ad from its preview or its Ad detail page. Rework the creative or move budget in Meta Ads Manager or Google Ads, outside Commander. | media buyer |
| A Scale or Strong group in By concept, By angle or By hook | Brief new creatives on the same idea. | creative strategist (the person who plans and makes ad creatives) |
| A low share of matched orders, or the tracking alert | Add the missing URL parameters in Meta Ads Manager, or the missing tag in Google Ads, as the alert says. Start with the Meta ads created in the last 24 hours: editing an older ad can send its ad set back into learning. This happens outside Commander. Until then, treat Matched revenue as understated. | media buyer |
| Unclassified group in a creative view | Commander has not analysed those ads yet. Review them one by one in By ad, or wait for the analysis. | media buyer |
| Unplaced or No benefit claim group | Open By ad to read those ads. Decide whether their message needs a clearer idea. | creative strategist |
Expected value and measurement
This page can help you see which ads earn their spend and where platform numbers and store profit disagree.
To check the effect of a change, open Performance > Ad performance. Compare two equal date ranges, before and after the change. On All Platforms, compare Gross profit after ad spend, its margin and You spent. The You spent card also shows the change from the prior period.
You cannot isolate one change when budgets, offers, prices or seasons moved at the same time.
Limitations and exceptions
- Klar columns. They are Klar's figures, a second opinion beside Meta's and Google's. They do not change True profit or Verdict. Grouped views other than ads and campaigns show a dash. See Connect Klar.
- Whole-store profit. Gross profit after ad spend includes orders from email, organic search and direct visits. It does not split by platform. On Meta or Google, the card asks you to switch to All Platforms.
- Platforms and dates. The page covers Meta and Google only, for at most 400 days.
- No order data. The profit cards show a dash and a reason line.
- Multiple groups. An ad can fall into several groups in By product and By collection. Commander counts its spend under each one, so Spend share can add up to more than 100%. A note under the table gives the real total.
- Unclassified. In a creative view, this group holds ads Commander has not analysed yet. After you connect an account, it can be large until Commander has analysed your ads. In By product and By collection, it holds ads Commander could not place on that view. Its Verdict cell reads Needs classification.
- Performance Max, No benefit claim and Unplaced. These fixed groups end a creative view. Their Verdict cell shows a dash, because Commander cannot judge them as one idea. A Performance Max asset group is never placed in a creative view. Only Commander's analysis of an ad's creative places it in the other groups. Tags from earlier analyses do not count in these views.
- No campaign linked and No ad set linked. In By campaign and By ad set, these groups hold ads Commander could not tie to a campaign or an ad set. Their Verdict cell shows a dash.
- Google spend on removed campaigns and ads. Google reports this spend only for the whole account, not for each ad. It is in no row of any view, Unclassified included, and in no Spend share. The table's spend can therefore be lower than You spent. A note under the table says so.
- Source filter. It narrows ads, not group totals. A group keeps its own figures even when only some of its ads show.
- Video columns. Hook rate, Hold rate, ThruPlay rate and Cost per ThruPlay cover Meta video ads only. Google ads, static ads and carousels show a dash. Hook rate, Hold rate and ThruPlay rate also need 1,000 impressions on days with video data. Cost per ThruPlay needs video data on every day of the range and some spend.
- Reach and frequency. Commander adds up Meta's daily reach over your dates and over the row's ads. Meta counts each person once across days and ads, so Reach reads higher, and Frequency lower, than Meta Ads Manager on a range of more than one day. Google ads show a dash.
- New customers. Commander counts the first orders it matched to the ad from your order and customer data, not what Meta or Google report. A Google match can count as part of an order, so the figure can have decimals. A dash means Commander cannot tell first orders apart for your store or for that ad. nCAC needs at least one whole first order and some spend. For a campaign or ad set it divides only the spend of the ads whose first orders Commander can tell apart.
- Ads not analysed yet. In a creative view, a note says what share of the ads Commander has analysed when that share is low. The groups then cover only part of your spend, and the rest sits in Unclassified. Commander analyses ads in separate steps, so after a change to your ads or accounts the share can stay low for a while.
- AI tags. AI sets each ad's answers. An answer can be wrong, and an ad can land in Unplaced when no option fits.
- Empty states. With no spend in the dates you pick, the table reads No ads with spend in this range. If the spend buttons match no ad, the page reads, for example, None of the ads in this period spent recently. With Format or Active ads only in use, it reads None of the ads in this period match these filters. Select Show all ads. If no ad matches your search, the table reads No ads match and your text. Select Clear search, or try a shorter part of the name. Before the first sync ends, the page reads Still preparing this view. After a sync that finds no ads, it reads Nothing here yet. Nothing shows until a campaign is live. Launch ads on your connected Meta or Google account. They appear after the next sync. If every step fails, it reads This view can't load yet. With no connected ad platform, it reads Connect a platform to unlock this view.
- Check now messages. Check already running means a Meta sync or check is in progress; the alert updates when it finishes. No connected Meta ad account means you connect Meta in Settings > Integrations. Couldn't check the ads means Commander could not reach Meta; try again later. Couldn't confirm the check finished means Commander could not read the check's status; the alert updates the next time it reads your Meta ads.
- Sync messages. Sync already running means you wait for the running sync, then retry. No connected Meta ad account, No connected Google ad account and No connected ad platform mean you connect the platform in Settings > Integrations, then retry. Last sync failed shows the reason beside it. No sync data yet means no sync has finished.
- Too much data. A note says when groups cannot expand or rows are missing. Narrow the date range.
- Long groups. An open group lists its first 50 ads. Select Show all with the count to see the rest.
- While a view loads. After you switch the view, the dates or the platform, the previous table stays on screen, dimmed, under a loading note. The new rows replace it when they arrive.
- Load errors. The numbers show Couldn't load your numbers. and the table shows Couldn't load your concepts. Each has a Retry button.
- Demo Mode. The data is sample data. The sync buttons do not start a real sync, and Check now on the tracking alert is disabled. Pause and Start change nothing on Meta or Google, and a note says so. In the public demo, both buttons are off. A note reads "Not available in the public demo. Keep this account to start and pause your own ads." Commander refuses creating a share link and creating a list, and tells you so.