Skip to content
Help Center

Competitor ad detail: read its analysis, create a similar ad and keep notes ​

The ad detail page shows one competitor ad in full. It holds the creative, its copy, how long it ran and Commander's analysis. You can also save the ad, create a similar ad from it and keep notes.

Problem and intended user ​

A creative strategist (the person who plans and makes ad creatives) sees a competitor ad in the library and needs to know why it might work. The message, the offer and the tone sit inside the ad, and a card cannot show them. A media buyer (the person who runs your paid ads) asks the same about the audience the ad targets. Without a clear read, each person judges the ad from a first impression, and the lessons stay with whoever noticed them.

Current workflow ​

Today you open the ad in the public ad library of Meta or Google and zoom in on the creative. You copy the headline and body text into a document. You write down the hook, the offer and the tone by hand. You paste the link into chat and add comments there, or you ask an agency for a teardown.

Prerequisites ​

  • Data. Open an ad from Competitor Library or the Inspiration Library. The ad must belong to a tracked competitor, an Inspiration brand or an industry peer.
  • Assets. Create similar ad needs an image or carousel ad.

How Commander works ​

Commander collects the creative, the copy and the run dates of each competitor ad from the platform's public ad data. Fixed rules count the days an ad ran. AI analyses the ads of the competitors you track after each sync and sets their Creative tags. For a video ad, that analysis also reads the video: what is said, the text on screen and how the video tells its story. The page has no button to start an analysis.

Open the page ​

Click View details on an ad card in Inspiration Library > Competitors > Competitor Library or in the Inspiration Library.

What each kind of ad offers ​

The page changes with the source of the ad.

SourceTabsAnalysisCreate similar ad
Competitor you trackOverview, NotesCreative tags, and Video evidence for a video adYes, for image and carousel ads
Inspiration brand or industry peer ad that is not from the shared ad catalogOverview, NotesCreative tags only when the ad has tags. Otherwise the page says "Inspiration ads are not analyzed" or "Industry peer ads are not analyzed".Yes, for image and carousel ads
Ad from the shared ad catalog. Its badge can read Competitor, Inspiration or Industry peer.Overview onlyThe page says "Catalog ads are not analyzed", unless the ad has tags.No

The tabs about performance, segment mix, attributed orders, linked products and logs belong to your own ads. See Ad detail.

Create a similar ad ​

Click Create similar ad in the header to open the clone setup for this ad. See Clone an ad.

  • Save ad keeps the ad. The button then reads Saved. Find saved ads in the Inspiration Library, under Saved ads.
  • Once the ad is saved, a folder chip shows its folder, or No folder. Click the chip to move the ad to another folder. The chip also shows when you open an ad that you saved earlier.
  • Copy link copies the address of this ad page and shows "Link copied". Another person on your Commander account reaches the same ad with it.

Keep notes on an ad ​

Open the Notes tab. The tab shows a count badge once the ad has notes.

  1. Type in the box under New note. Click the emoji button to add an emoji.
  2. Click Post note.
  3. Click Reply under a note to answer it.
  4. Open More options on a note to Edit or Delete it. Delete asks you to confirm first. Deleting a note also deletes its replies, and you cannot undo it. To delete a reply, open Reply options on it and select Delete. It asks for the same confirmation.

Exact output ​

The page opens with a breadcrumb. It reads Inspiration Library > Competitors for a tracked competitor. It reads Inspiration Library for an Inspiration brand or an industry peer. The title is the ad's headline, or the first words of its text when there is no headline. Under it sit the brand and the source: Competitor, Inspiration or Industry peer. A King ad badge shows next to the title for a likely winner. Point at the badge to read the rule. The header holds Create similar ad, Save ad and a … menu with Save to folder or Move to folder, Copy link and Open landing page. When you came from the Inspiration Library, the breadcrumb reads Inspiration Library, then the ad, then Full analysis.

The Overview tab ​

A panel on the left shows the ad as it runs: every card of a carousel, or the video. When Commander has no picture of the ad, the panel says so and shows the ad's text. Click the creative to enlarge it or play it. The Overview shows:

  • At a glance. How long the ad has run and since when, whether it is Live or Ended, the King ad reason when it is one, and the landing page. A line under it says Commander cannot see the brand's sales or spend, so these are signals, not results.
  • Details. The brand, with All their ads, the platform with its placements, the format, when the ad started and when Commander last saw it, the advertiser, the number of variations, Ad family, Made from this ad, Same creative, Est. impressions (EU) and Est. spend (EU) when they exist, Ad library, the Angle and Hook tags when the ad has them, and the ad ID. Dates show as exact days.
    • Ad family names the group of related ads that Commander found for this ad. It gives the number of ads in the group and how many run now, and adds "ran longest" when this ad ran longest. The row is missing when Commander has not grouped the ad.
    • Made from this ad lists the creative batches you started from this ad with Create similar ad. It gives the number of batches, then links to the newest ones, and "and" a number "more" when there are more. The row is missing when there is no batch. It never shows for an ad from the shared ad catalog.
    • Same creative reads "Used in" a count "ads (grouped by Meta)". It shows when Meta grouped the ad with copies of the same creative. It is not the same as the number of variations.
    • Ad library links to the ad in the public ad library: View in Meta Ad Library or View in Google Ads Transparency Center. The link opens in a new tab.
  • Reach and delivery (EU and UK) for a Meta ad, below Details. It shows the reach Meta discloses for the EU and the UK.

The Overview also holds these cards:

CardWhat it shows
Creative analysisOne card. The ad's Creative tags come first, then Video evidence for a video ad. You can read them but not change them. The tags do not show for a catalog ad, or when Commander has no labels for the ad. The page shows no other AI analysis of the creative.
Creative tagsAt the top of Creative analysis, one row each. The ad's tag on ten parts of the creative: Concept, Angle, Hook, Offer, Trigger, Visual, Awareness, Message clarity, Text density and Scroll-stop power. A tag reads No benefit claim (Angle only) when the ad claims no benefit, Unplaced when no option fits, or Unclassified when Commander analysed that part but has no tag for it. An ad with no image or video can be tagged from its text only. Its Visual, Text density and Scroll-stop power then read Not analysed, because they need the picture. Hook topic, Call to action, Objection, Audience, Tone, Moment, Execution and Ingredient follow and read Not analysed: the tags do not cover them. Tone leaves that list when Video evidence shows the video's tone. On a tracked competitor's ad without tags, a note reads "Ad Bucketing has not analysed this ad yet." and every tag reads Not analysed. An Inspiration or industry-peer ad shows a Creative tags section instead, only when it has tags. That section adds the family of the Angle.
Video evidenceWhat Commander read from a video ad when it set the tags: Length, Audio, Pacing, Tone, First 3 seconds, Story, On-screen text and the Transcript. A row is missing when Commander has no value for it. The transcript reads "No speech in this video." when nobody speaks, and "The transcript is not available for this ad." when someone speaks but Commander has no transcript. It does not show for an image ad, for a video Commander has not analysed yet, or for a video whose analysis has no transcript or on-screen text.

What to do with it ​

What you seeDecision or actionOwner
Creative tags and Video evidenceDecide which ideas to borrow or avoid, then write them into the brief.creative strategist
At a glance and the run dates in DetailsDecide whether the ad deserves a closer look. A long run is a hint, not proof.creative strategist
Create similar adClick it to open the batch setup with this ad as its starting point, then choose your own product.creative strategist
Save ad and Copy linkKeep the ad, or send the page to another person on your Commander account.creative strategist
NotesRecord why the ad matters and answer others in Reply.creative strategist

Expected value and measurement ​

The page can help you read a competitor ad in one place and brief from its analysis.

To check the analysis, read or watch the ad yourself and compare it with the Creative tags and the Video evidence in Creative analysis. Commander shows no accuracy score for an analysis. To check your own results, open Performance > Ad performance, select By ad, and compare ROAS and CPA for ads you made with Create similar ad against your other ads over the same dates. Performance does not mark these ads, so note which ads you made this way. The effect cannot be isolated. Offer, product and budget change at the same time. For the competitor ad, Commander shows how long it ran and the estimates above, not its sales or click results.

Limitations and exceptions ​

What is not supported ​

  • The page has no Analyze button. Commander analyses the ads of the competitors you track on its own, after each sync.
  • Video ads and text ads show no Create similar ad button. Catalog ads show none either.
  • Save ad does not appear for the ads of a competitor you removed from tracking.
  • Ad family exists for the ads of competitors you track and for Inspiration and industry peer ads that are not from the shared ad catalog. It never shows for an ad from the shared ad catalog.
  • An ad that a newer copy has replaced no longer opens. The page reads "We couldn’t find this ad". An ad of this kind that you saved stays in your saved ads.

Estimates and AI output ​

Est. impressions (EU) and Est. spend (EU) are estimates and show only when they exist for the ad. Ad library shows only when the ad has a link to Meta's or Google's public ad library. The Creative tags and the Video evidence in Creative analysis come from AI and can be wrong. A transcript can miss or mishear words. You cannot change a tag by hand.

Messages and failures ​

You seeWhat to do
Ad Bucketing has not analysed this ad yet.Commander analyses the ads of tracked competitors after the sync, so this can take a while. There is no button to start it from this page.
We couldn’t find this adThe ad may have been removed, or the link is incomplete. Use the back link on the page.
We couldn’t load this adClick Try again.
Link copiedThe link is on your clipboard.
Couldn’t copy the linkCopy the address from the browser.

Demo Mode ​

In Demo Mode, the Creative tags and Video evidence are sample data. Commander blocks saving an ad and tells you so. Create similar ad opens the batch setup on sample data, and nothing is generated for real. See Demo Mode and sample data.

Commander is built by Omniconvert.